Monday, October 29, 2012

Is the U.S. an exceptional country?


Sharon Ettinger

            “Do you guys really go to school in big yellow busses?”
            In broken English, my sister’s friend Sara asked us an apparently commonly pondered question from her home in Barcelona. She brushed a strand of hair from her cheek as the brisk New England winter air whistled past, and the distant rumbling of a bus momentarily grasped her attention that was so intensely focused on the other side of her thick camera lens. She could not be any more ostentatious—wandering the casual streets of Lexington center, her colorful pants flowed in the wind as she captured photographs of the simplest details with her huge black camera, catching every passerby’s curious eye. Sara took no notice to this attention, as she was rapt in the wonders of the stores and benches and sidewalks. Her amazement of such simplicity in our culture was remarkable.
Before her visit here, Sara had studied in several other countries beforehand including Spain, Denmark, and Ireland, but something she never ceased to glorify during her visit here was the outstanding education. Upon asking her about her past experiences studying abroad, she let out a shy laugh and stated simply, “It is all better here.” Watching her sit at our kitchen table with her nose inches from her work, I came to realize that students from all over the world are constantly grasping opportunities to study in America.
“Would you like to stay for dinner?”
Sara freed herself from her tangle of work to meet my mom’s gaze. A simple question, yet Sara’s eyes were bright as she graciously accepted. I couldn’t help but to notice throughout our routinely family dinner the state of awe she was in. Pass the salad? She jumped to pass it; a smile laced with nervousness and suppressed joy tempting her lips.
As I later learned, this evident exhilaration was a result of her finally living the long aspired “American dream”. She had finally started living it, triggered by that simple family dinner that contrasted so drastically with her uneasy relationship with each member of her family, who she no longer lived with. The family, the jobs, the schools, and the smiles—all came together to be the American dream of which Sara would whisper her envy to my sister before her stay here.
A few months passed after Sara’s stay, after which she moved into an apartment in New York, but our hosting wasn’t over—this time it was Jen, a family friend from England whose plan to visit was a pleasant surprise. But the excitement of her visit was lined with negative connotations: a long suffering patient of lime disease, she had to quickly make arrangements to come to the United States when her doctors turned to American medics after struggling with her particularly severe case.
The airport was its same restless self as we sat impatiently on a particularly hard bench just outside of Jen’s gate. Disheveled passengers with bloodshot eyes and wrinkled clothes began to slowly trickle off the plane. We sat craning our necks over the crowd of groggy passengers until it seemed the very last one had exited, and then emerging slowly through the gate door was Jen, escorted in a wheelchair by a flight attendant. It was such an odd sight—her hands were folded neatly as she rolled towards us in the chair but the precious freshness in her twenty-year-old face screamed that she should be taking advantage of her youth instead of dealing with the toll lime disease had taken on her weak body. Still she smiled, tired as she was, for now that she was finally in America the thought that this might just be where her life goes back to normal officially set in.
She stayed for a few months, and by the end of it every high-class doctor we could think of was mulling over her case that had stumped so many doctors back in England. Her hopes were high—doctors in the United States never fail, right?
This is another example of America’s incredible reputation. Both Sara’s and Jen’s situations are just one out of thousands of examples where people around the world focus on America’s greatness, dreaming to someday travel here to experience the life they’ve been admiring or to improve their lives off of things like education or health care. The United States is an exceptional country, because it has achieved such distinctiveness in its balance among all of the significant aspects of a strong and successful nation that other countries do indeed admire at even the slightest details.

6 comments:

  1. Sharon, really nice job. The descriptiveness of the two characters made them feel like real people (they very well might be) and I could especially imagine Sara wander aimlessly around Lexington Center. A couple things to work on here is perhaps a little more background information on the characters, and maybe how the other members of your family reacted to them. (When Sara replies to your mom with abundant eagerness, how does your mother react?). I'm also assuming that the disease that Jen has is also called Lyme's Disease, or Lyme Disease, not Lime, unless she has some new ailment that makes her green or something. Really interesting piece though, and I enjoyed your closing paragraph.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I loved this! You wrote it with a lot of thought and got the message across really well through a story. I liked the style of writing that you chose because it made the topic very personal and showed how well you can relate to the question. It also got the reader very involved in the story because it left us wanting to know what happened next and how the two girls would end up. I agree with Josh that it would have added something if you included a brief background of the two of them, maybe youre relationship before their visits. Overall, I enjoyed reading your writing and I think that you answered the question very well.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sharon this is very well done. Like Josh mentioned, your descriptions of the characters and the settings are awesome. For instance, your details when talking about Sara "intensely focused on the other side of her thick camera lens" and the "groggy crowd of passengers" at the airport really created a picture in my mind. Your approach was very cool, pulling in two different characters and two different stories with different perceptions of how foreigners view America as exceptional. The idea of the school bus, so normal to us, yet Sara was so phased by it and saw it as a sign of the American dream was a nice subtle yet very interesting example. The only negative criticism I have is that I feel a little as though you rushed into bringing Jen into the story; I had to read it over again to understand the transition. Besides that nice job!!

    ReplyDelete
  4. One thing that I really liked in your essay was your analysis of Saras's thoughts, opinions, and actions. Sara's opinions of the US combined with your analysis of her opinions formed a great argument to prove that America truly is exceptional, even in the eyes of foreigners. You opened your arguments to the reader very well by giving a foreign thought, opinion, or action towards the US before fully explaining you piece of evidence. This gave your supporting evidence real life feeling to them, making it even more convincing to the reader. One of the pieces of evidence that popped out to me was to great quality of medicine the US has. You opened to the argument very well by explaining that your friend Jen had to "come to the United States when her doctors turned to American medics after struggling with her particularly severe case". The fact that foreigners are being sent to the US for medical treatment is a great indicator that America truly is exceptional-at least in the medical sector. One thing you could do to enhance your argument is give more evidence to support your argument. The arguments you gave were great but I felt as though bits and pieces were missing. Just an idea- you could add some facts about the American educational system and the American medical sector. Great job!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I enjoyed reading this! Your piece is organized well and in a way that makes it relatable and easy for the reader to follow so great job! I think you did a commendable job of painting pictures with your words throughout this narrative and I especially loved the sentence, “ She brushed a strand of hair from her cheek as the brisk New England winter air whistled past, and the distant rumbling of a bus momentarily grasped her attention that was so intensely focused on the other side of her thick camera lens”. This sentence is specific, and the words are clearly well chosen to such a degree that it enables the reader to envision this part of the story. I would love it if you gave more information on Sara’s family history and experiences because that could add a more interesting and specific element to the story. I also think that you need more background on Jen because the section about her feels a tad rushed, however you still managed to communicate the idea of America being exceptional through her story so good job! The last paragraph ties in your argument well but it reads a little bit like an argumentative essay, which contradicts the rest of your essay because the rest is in a narrative format. It is only noticeable because you did well with making the other part of your essay relatable, so maybe edit the last paragraph and add in elements of personality and imagery like you did before. Great job Sharon; this was an interesting and creative piece!

    ReplyDelete
  6. I really liked how your last paragraph was different from the narrative style of the rest of your writing. It was an interesting twist but helped summarize and really pull together your thoughts on American exceptionalism. Using characters from different cultures and describing their experience in the U.S. was a great way to exemplify your argument. The descriptive language you used was also creative and powerful, and I especially liked how you described Sara's smile as "a smile laced with nervousness and suppressed joy tempting her lips". However, I think the part on Jen is rushed and needs more elaboration to add to your argument. Perhaps you could tell the story of whether or not the American doctors succeeded in what the British doctors were not able to accomplish to really show the exceptionalism of the U.S. There were also a couple of grammatical errors that you may want to look over. But overall, I think you did a great job and I enjoyed reading this piece.

    ReplyDelete